The Gang of 8 are Wrong on Immigration Reform

Bader-Qarmout-portrait-picBy Bader George Qarmout

As Washington debates immigration reform and the bi-partisan gang of 8 push their latest plan, I find myself disagreeing with the plan’s failure to secure the border FIRST. It is imperative that we fix the mistakes of Ronald Reagan’s Congress that failed us forty years ago.  Securing our borders is not only a means to prevent illegal workers from entering America, but it is also an important tool for greater national security and to reduce the onslaught of drug, weapons, and human trafficking . I will not accept any arguments that stress that the cost of securing our borders is prohibitive. I argue that not securing our borders is unconscionable.

While we are securing the borders, we need to enforce our existing laws and make E-verify mandatory.  We also need to deport the criminal illegal aliens who are currently sitting in our jails and prisons.  It is cost effective to permanently remove the criminal elements from among us, as opposed to the current “catch and release” practice.

For the remaining millions of illegal aliens who are already here, who may have American born children, or who are in a sector that is dependent on migrant workers, I still do not support amnesty. If they are to stay, they must register (H1 temporary work status) pay a hefty fine, and go to the back of the line. I believe, as I already proposed, a $10,000.00 fine (to be deducted automatically from payroll by employer weekly), and a 10 year back of the line period to learn English, work, pay taxes, and pledge allegiance to this great nation is needed. I do not believe during the 10 year back of the line period they should be eligible to collect any entitlements or vote. At the end of the 10 year back of the line period and the paying in full of the $10,000.00 fine, they would follow current rules to apply for a Green Card. As green Card holders, they are still prohibited from voting.

If we take, as an average, the 15 million illegal aliens currently in the US, the $10,000.00 fee would generate $150 Billion, along with increase in tax revenue from workers who would be able to pay taxes and open a bank account so more of their earned income can stay in America.

Anyone who proposes we do something that is undoable is supporting amnesty. We must realize that the current broken immigration system and unsecure borders is in fact AMNESTY and we need to first secure of sovereign borders if we are sincere about immigration reform once and for all.


Posted: June 24th, 2013 | Author: | Filed under: Bader George Qarmout, Immigration, Opinion | Tags: , | 4 Comments »

4 Comments on “The Gang of 8 are Wrong on Immigration Reform”

  1. Yes said at 12:50 pm on June 24th, 2013:

    He gets it. Perfectly outlined, now they should heed his advice, draw it up, vote on it, pass it, and implement it immediately.

  2. Barry said at 1:16 pm on June 24th, 2013:

    No one who is not a citiizen can legally vote so no one is proposing these legalized individuals be able to vote. Everyone should be aware once the individuals are legalized you cannot limit their ability to receive in state tuition and tuition assistance.

    In addition, no one who is disabled or aged will be required to pay any fine. Current law already exempts disabled and aged from having to learn English to become citizens.

    FYI 40 years ago Ronald Reagan was Governor of California and Richard Nixon was President. The Reagan (Simpson-Rodino) immigration amnesty was in 1986.

  3. Rev Mi.chael Hahn said at 2:08 pm on June 24th, 2013:

    Lets go back to old land Mark ellis island!

  4. Rev Mi.chael Hahn said at 2:12 pm on June 24th, 2013:

    Lets go back to old land Mark ellis island!
    one of checks and ballances
    dem lie about fruit pickers its agenda 21
    what fruit picken in newark nj sancuary dem c ity!